When the IRS rejects a payment proposal or threatens a bank levy, wage garnishment, federal tax lien, or seizure, it can feel as though the decision is final.
In many cases, it is not.
Depending on the collection action, the notice you received, and the procedural history of your case, you may have the right to ask the IRS Independent Office of Appeals to review the decision. However, these rights are highly dependent on deadlines. Waiting too long can allow the IRS to move forward with enforcement.
Two Ways to Appeal an IRS Collection Decision
The two primary procedures for challenging an IRS collection decision are the Collection Appeals Program and a Collection Due Process hearing. Although both involve IRS Appeals, they serve different purposes and provide different rights.
The Collection Appeals Program
The Collection Appeals Program, commonly called CAP, provides a relatively fast review of certain IRS collection decisions.
CAP may be available when the IRS:
- Proposes or files a federal tax lien
- Proposes a levy or seizure
- Rejects, modifies, or terminates an installment agreement
- Refuses to release a levy
- Rejects a taxpayer’s proposed collection solution
For example, a Revenue Officer may reject a proposed payment plan and threaten enforcement. Before requesting a CAP appeal, the taxpayer will ordinarily ask for a conference with the Revenue Officer’s manager.
During that conference, the taxpayer should explain specifically why the decision is unreasonable or unsupported. This may involve correcting the IRS’s calculation of income, documenting necessary living expenses, explaining health problems, addressing asset values, or proposing a more realistic collection alternative.
If the manager upholds the decision, the taxpayer may be able to request a CAP appeal, generally using Form 9423, Collection Appeal Request.
CAP decisions are usually made quickly, which can be valuable when enforcement is imminent. However, CAP has limitations. It generally cannot be used to dispute whether the tax is actually owed, and an unfavorable CAP decision cannot ordinarily be appealed to the United States Tax Court.
Collection Due Process Hearings
A Collection Due Process hearing, commonly called a CDP hearing, may be available after the IRS files a Notice of Federal Tax Lien or sends a final notice of intent to levy.
Final levy notices may include an LT11, Letter 1058, or certain CP90 notices. The taxpayer generally has 30 days from the date of the notice to request a CDP hearing by submitting Form 12153.
A timely CDP request is especially important because it will generally prevent the proposed levy from moving forward while the hearing is pending. It also preserves the taxpayer’s right to petition the United States Tax Court if the taxpayer disagrees with the Appeals determination.
During a CDP hearing, the taxpayer may be able to:
- Challenge whether the IRS followed the proper collection procedures
- Propose an installment agreement
- Request currently not collectible status
- Submit an Offer in Compromise
- Raise certain spousal defenses
- Challenge the underlying tax liability in limited circumstances
A taxpayer generally cannot challenge the underlying liability during a CDP hearing if there was already a meaningful opportunity to dispute it.
What Makes a Collection Appeal Stronger?
An effective collection appeal should do more than state that the IRS’s decision is unfair or that the requested payment is unaffordable.
A stronger appeal will:
- Identify the exact collection decision being challenged.
- Explain why the decision is unreasonable or procedurally incorrect.
- Provide documents supporting the taxpayer’s financial position.
- Present a realistic alternative to the proposed enforcement action.
- Confirm that all required returns have been filed and current tax obligations are being paid.
IRS Appeals will generally not approve a collection alternative if the taxpayer is not in filing or payment compliance.
Do Not Wait Until Enforcement Begins
One of the biggest mistakes taxpayers make is waiting until the IRS has already taken money from a bank account or paycheck.
Appeal deadlines can be extremely short. In some CAP situations, a taxpayer may have only a few business days after a manager conference to notify the IRS that an appeal is being requested. Other notices, including those involving installment agreements or Collection Due Process rights, may provide a 30-day response period.
Every IRS notice should be reviewed immediately. Pay close attention to the notice date, the type of collection action being proposed, the appeal procedure provided, and the response deadline.
An aggressive IRS collection decision may be appealable, but those rights can disappear if the taxpayer fails to act in time.
In the video below, I explain the differences between the Collection Appeals Program and a Collection Due Process hearing, including when each procedure may apply and how an appeal can help prevent enforcement while the case is reviewed.
[Watch the video: How to Appeal an Aggressive IRS Collection Decision Before Enforcement Begins]
If you are facing an IRS levy, federal tax lien, seizure, rejected payment plan, or unreasonable collection demand, professional representation may help you determine which appeal procedure is available and how to present a supported alternative before the deadline expires. Reach out to us at Tax Relief Consultation – Jablonsky Tax Relief
This article provides general educational information and should not be considered tax or legal advice for any individual situation.
